Land Rover owner JLR has gone to court in the Netherlands over allegations that BYD's Ti7 SUV infringes intellectual property tied to the Defender. Bailiffs acting for JLR seized digital records from BYD offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp in August, The Guardian reported, citing The Sunday Times.
No court has ruled that BYD copied anything. A court in The Hague is expected to rule this week on procedural questions, including whether the case can go ahead and which seized records JLR can use, The Telegraph said. Motor1 put a preliminary ruling on November 11, and The Guardian said the court will decide whether BYD has a case to answer. Auto Express described Wednesday's session as a preliminary hearing.
JLR wanted the records secured before they could be destroyed, The Guardian said. The two companies met in a Hague courtroom in October to argue over how the files could be used, The Telegraph reported. BYD reportedly called the seizure a "fishing expedition," and Motor1 said BYD's lawyers argued too many files were taken. JLR's legal advisers accused BYD of obstructing the process, Motor1 said.
Neither side is talking. "JLR does not comment on ongoing legal proceedings," a JLR spokesperson said. BYD told Motor1, "We have no comment to make at this time."
Published reports describe the claim only as intellectual property infringement. They don't say whether JLR is relying on a registered design, a trademark, or unfair competition law. They also differ on the focus. The Telegraph said JLR reportedly wants evidence that BYD set out to copy the Defender's design. The Guardian said JLR suspects BYD reverse-engineered technology that could be used in the Ti7, and Top Gear said JLR was looking for documents about the stripping down of a Defender.

The Ti7 went on sale in China in September 2025 as the Fangchengbao Ti7, Motor1 said. BYD's website pitches "an unapologetically boxy profile" and an "imposing, chunky design." Auto Express wrote in its review that from some angles you would be hard-pressed to tell it from a Defender, pointing to blocky bodywork, contrasting bumpers, and a floating roof. Top Gear called it a "Chinese Defender clone" in August. Motor1 saw similarities but said "calling it a carbon copy would be going too far." Those are reviewers' opinions. No report lists the design features JLR has put before the court.
The Ti7 is due in the UK in January from £47,995, while a seven-seat Defender 110 starts at £68,465, Motor1 said. It is about 5 meters long, similar to the Defender 110, and uses a 1.5-liter plug-in hybrid setup, Auto Express said. JLR sold 29,500 Defenders to retail customers from July to September, up from 25,370 a year earlier, The Guardian said. JLR ultimately wants the car kept off the European market, but the case won't be resolved before the January launch, The Telegraph reported.
JLR has tested shape claims before, with mixed results. On March 22, 2019, it announced that the Beijing Chaoyang District Court had found five unique features of the Range Rover Evoque were copied in the Landwind X7, and had ordered sales, manufacturing, and marketing of that car to stop. JLR's Chinese design patent was invalidated because of its own earlier public exhibition of the car, law firm Marks & Clerk said, so unfair competition law carried the win. The copyright claim failed. The Beijing Intellectual Property Court affirmed the unfair competition win on appeal in May 2021.
The Defender itself has been harder to protect. In 2020, JLR lost a UK court attempt to trademark the classic Defender's shape after the Intellectual Property Office found it wasn't distinctive enough, Hagerty reported. That left Ineos free to build the similar-looking Grenadier. Land Rover executives are still being asked about Chinese Range Rover lookalikes.
Is a boxy SUV fair game, or did this one get too close? Cast your vote on WhipJury.
Sources:
The August seizure, its locations, the case-to-answer question, the reverse-engineering suspicion, the BYD website quote, and Defender retail sales: The Guardian
The October courtroom session, the procedural ruling, the "fishing expedition" line, the design-evidence goal, and the European market aim: The Telegraph via Yahoo Finance
The November 11 date, both company statements, the lawyers' arguments, the Fangchengbao name and China sale date, UK prices, and the "carbon copy" line: Motor1
The preliminary hearing, the Ti7's length, and its powertrain: Auto Express
The Ti7's bodywork, bumpers, and floating roof: Auto Express review
Documents about stripping down a Defender: Top Gear. The "Chinese Defender clone" label: Top Gear
The 2019 Beijing Chaoyang ruling, five features, and sales stop: JLR Media Newsroom
The invalidated design patent, the failed copyright claim, and the unfair competition route: Marks & Clerk
The 2021 appeal: China IP Law Update
The 2020 Defender trademark loss and Ineos: Hagerty
Photos: Defender by Mr.choppers, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0; Fangchengbao Ti7 by S5A-0043, licensed under CC BY 4.0
Frequently Asked Questions

Jeffrey Wiley has spent more time than he'd like to admit thinking about what makes a car look right. He writes about automotive design, car culture, and the opinions people have strong feelings about. He lives in north Georgia.
